Caught in a Bubble

 

by Michael D. Swords

 

Bubbles. What could they have to do with our favorite mystery? I must admit that the answer to that might be “nothing,” but let’s look at this a bit anyway.

Ryan GravesI have, along with you, been watching the parade of whistleblowers showing up all over the television, and I don’t really know what to make of them. So I wait for something more. Sometimes in their claims something will stir an old thought. That happened in one of Ryan Graves’s comments. Alongside his statements about cubes-in-spheres (which got more press), he tossed out a case of witnesses at Vandenberg Air Force Base on October 14, 2003, seeing a huge square object approach the base and hover for 45 seconds over the facilities. What was most interesting to me was that the object, which stopped at one point pretty much overhead, was one of the big ones—judged to be a football field or more on a side—yet, when it darted off over the mountains, it caused no boom nor even any reportable movement of air.  So, apparently it was a very big thing, but with no evidence of normal air displacement. Now just how do you get your head around that? (“Air Force Officer Breaks Silence over ‘Red, Glowing’ UFO Sighting: ‘This Is Not a Joke,’” The Independent (UK), November 10, 2023)

The US Air Force investigators from the very beginning asked themselves that same question about UFOs: Why no sonic booms? Why no apparent air displacement? The answers they came up with were insufficient to say the least: “The event didn’t even happen,” “The observers forgot that part, or were semi deaf,” “Whatever this was, it didn’t have mass. It must have been just light.” . . . or other concepts that, as cases and observers mounted, made no sense at all for many of the encounters in the files. The practical answer was to shrug and forget about that part. And even we ufologists did just that.

JAL caseOn November 17, 1986, Captain Kenju Terauchi was minding his business piloting commercial flight JAL 1628 in Alaskan airspace, when he noticed several odd lights. He naturally got extremely alarmed and called for information from air traffic control. Yep. There was unscheduled traffic. One part of that traffic was gigantic. It was hard to discern precisely, but it dwarfed the 747. It eerily followed for a while, then was suddenly gone … and with no air effects. One wonders why half the air in the sky was not chaotically whipped about when that thing left the area. (Bruce Maccabee, “The Fantastic Flight of JAL 1628,” International UFO Reporter 12, no. 2 (March/April 1987): 4–23)

Did the event happen? Well, yes, despite attempts to hide the data. Did the witnesses forget that their plane was rocked about by turbulence? Well, no. This was a professional crew. Was the gigantic object just a light? Well, maybe. But it looked like a thing, not a big ball of light.

Hollard radar caseSo, shrug, I guess. Another time it was March 8, 1994, and UFO chatter was all across west Michigan. The whole nation was briefly fired up about the local UFO wave that featured the voice of a young National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) radar operator excitedly describing what he was seeing in real time. That recording carried the case into national prominence, and it actually deserved it. But amateur UFO investigators of all sorts of nuttiness poured into the region, violating witnesses’ privacy and causing a veritable hullaballoo. NOAA was worried about its role. They were up before Congress at the time, and were sensitive to being quoted by nuts on the one hand or getting accused of a cover-up on the other. They needed some kind of middle-of-the-road solution. (Michael D. Swords, “The Holland, Michigan, Radar-Visual Case, 1994,” International UFO Reporter 24, no. 3 (Fall 1999): 3–7)

My great friend and UFO-buddy, Dave Ford, gave them one. As a good field researcher should, Dave went right to the source and called NOAA headquarters in Washington, D.C. They were of course skeptical. But he offered them as a responsible source a science professor at the big local school, Western Michigan University. Me. Well, they thought that’s a fine idea, and soon Dave came to my home and said: “Mike, get in the car. We’re headed for Muskegon.” Momentarily taken aback (I didn’t have much incentive at the moment to ride to Muskegon, despite it being a nice town), with a little explanation we left.

There at the Muskegon National Weather Service radar station we were treated with utmost professionalism and friendliness by the director and his young protege radarman, Jack Bushong. Jack was good at his job, a technical artiste, and he took us through all the equipment that he used, and then we settled in for his illustrated presentation of what happened that night. To do that, he utilized a big illuminated display surface upon which he could draw the positions and subsequent changes of the UFOs as they marched down the western Michigan coastline and out onto Lake Michigan. I sat there sketching everything. When the director saw me doing this, not only did he approve but offered me a stack of maps matching Jack’s display to make the task easier. As I said: Very professional and friendly.

I sketched every step of Jack’s rather vivid experience with the radar that evening. It was published in my article in the International UFO Reporter in 1999. The session included some amazing things. These blips were huge, far bigger than those of a commercial aircraft. And they were different in other ways. Jack showed us how a plane looks and how rainclouds look and described how these were totally different and easily distinguishable. The blips were shaped oddly (like big, double-lobed, kidney-shaped patches of space), and they moved extremely oddly—suddenly, in between one-second painting sweeps, jumping to a widely different spot. They moved in this way as a group, but also oddly. One return would move out of a roughly triangular formation, but the others would wait. Then they would move to re-form the pattern. It looked very intelligent.

When we were finished, the director had only one request: Could he please make copies of my sketches of the patterns of motions? These he said would form the basis of their report to NOAA headquarters about what went on. I of course was happy to do so. We left all smiles. The phenomenology became more and more intriguing the more one looked at it. The early witness sightings were of ordinary-sized disks but later visual reports fizzled out largely due to the idiot invasive behaviors driving witnesses away. Very little visually got into the records during the time Jack Bushong was seeing the big double-lobed radar returns. The interfering, so-called ufologists were to blame. But what might we deduce from what we do know?

Those returns occupied very large areas of the sky, three times or greater than big planes. And when they jumped, they did so with a shocking suddenness. They were here in one big air space; then a second later, they were there in a different large airspace. And, no surprise: no signs of booms or displaced air here either. There was a very dramatic moment in the radar tracking when the UFOs ascended extremely rapidly, rising at a minimum speed of slightly less than 1,000 mph. Again, no boom, no air disturbances from them.

A powerhouse of a Close Encounter

Coyne caseOne of our favorite cases is the Captain Lawrence Coyne case on October 18, 1973, in Mansfield, Ohio: an in-air dance between a UFO and a helicopter. We all know the details. In some ways of figuring, this is the best, most undeniably anomalous encounter in UFO history. It has multiple, independent witnesses of high character both in the air and on the ground, plenty of observing time and strange effects, and witnesses who have firmly stuck by what they reported. It has an unorthodox object interfering with an Army helicopter in strongly forceful ways, not only blocking the flight path but messing with the technology on board to the extent of hauling the helicopter significantly upwards, despite the crew’s efforts to put a stop to that. The entire incident was watched by a civilian family from their car on the ground, and their description matches all the pilot’s details. (Jennie Zeidman, A Helicopter-UFO Encounter over Ohio, Center for UFO Studies, 1979)

Within the voluminous testimonies, there is a detail that, to my mind, has received almost no attention, let alone amazed comment. About the time the interfering UFO shone a green beam into the cabin, Captain Coyne had decided that this potential collision course was extremely dangerous and put the helicopter into a crash dive to get away—but they couldn’t. The craft and the beam were still right with them. And now the extremely odd thing: instead of dropping down, as they were trying to do, their instruments were showing a rapid ascent instead. Their equipment had been overridden, and they were being dragged upward by the object. Coyne tried to exert power against the strange pull to no effect (other than the helicopter seemed to vibrate against the opposing force). In fact, and here it is, there was profoundly no effect involving normal physics. That is, when the pulling began, reversing a rapid falling course into a rapid rising course, the crew felt no change such as one would expect from inertia. No sinking in the seat, nor any such sensation. It was, for them, as if normalcy for those moments did not involve the pull of Earth’s gravity. Or (can we risk saying it?) as if they were in some isolated space or bubble where light moved freely between inside and outside, but some other important things stayed separately in different homes.

Other aspects of the Coyne case can be mentioned to enhance the strangeness (the early canceling out of radio function, the demagnetization of the compass, the bump sensation as the pulling beam switched off and the helicopter once more flew free, and the return of radio function at that point), but for me that subtle notice of no expected inertial effect stands out. Someone smarter than me might be able make more sense of it.

Boyup Brook caseBut the phenomenon might not stand alone. On October 30, 1967, Alexander Spargo was driving on the Mayanup-Kojonup Road in Western Australia at about 9:30 p.m. He was on a deserted patch of the road and going 60–65 mph. A tube of light entered his vehicle. Silent, it emanated from a 30-foot diameter craft, pulsating with bluish light. His engine then just shut off. His lights and radio did also. The outside of the penetrating tube was very bright white light, but the inside was easily viewable with no glare. Unfortunately, there was nothing to see inside nor up towards the tube’s end. Everything seemed without sound for about five minutes. Then, the light went off, and the object disappeared at great speed to the west.

Now the real oddity: When the light went off and the craft disappeared, the automobile was moving normally down the road with all systems functioning. Stunned by this, the driver stopped his car and got out. Everything seemed okay, but his watch was off by 5 minutes. More importantly, he realized that he had no sense of any deceleration initially when he was stopped nor any sense of acceleration when his car was moving again on the road. As with the Coyne crew, he had an experience wherein the law of inertia didn’t seem to work. (Keith Basterfield, “Police Report on the Boyup Brook Encounter, Uncovered,” Unidentified Aerial Phenomena—Scientific Research, August 29, 2017)

Or did it, and for a little while he wasn’t quite around good old gravity-fat Mother Earth? Was he in a weird bubble of some kind? Mass effects? On a different playing field and time?

The Oz Factor: Bizarre UFO wizardry

One more sort of phenomenon (to ensure that I’ve thoroughly exhausted any claim to rationality I might have seemed to have): The Oz Factor—what British UFO researcher Jenny Randles refers to as the “sensation of being isolated, or transported from the real world into a different environmental framework.” (Jenny Randles, “In Search of the Oz Factor,” BUFORA Bulletin 26 (July 1987): 17–18)

Let’s go with our old friend John Timmerman, the late treasurer for the Center for UFO Studies (CUFOS), to Bossier City, Louisiana, for another example. In January 1989, John was puttering around his CUFOS traveling UFO exhibit making some very needed money for the organization. Projecting, as always, his charming friendly self, people happily came up to him to tell him of their own UFO encounters. John immortalized them by tape-recording them right on the spot. On this day one of the visitors was a young married man, who wanted to tell John of his and his daughter’s encounter on January 19, 1988.

Bossier City caseThe witness and his family were residents of nearby Benton, Louisiana, and the wife worked in a store in the Pierre Bossier Mall. It was the husband’s habit to take their daughter and show up at the rear entrance parking lot to pick his wife up after work. It was, therefore, almost exactly 5:00 p.m. when this occurred. They were there only a brief period of time when the daughter said, “Look! What is that?” She had seen a flash of light over the nearby turnpike, and he then noticed a rapid streak of light. In a blink, the result was an object hovering about 30–50 yards away in an empty line of sight (they thought it had deliberately stopped right in front of them), spinning in the air.

The object was a little thing and almost silly. It was only 12 feet in diameter and 5 feet tall, silver with no structure except depressions that the witness called “turbines.” No sound issued from them as the UFO turned. Then, out of the top came a “sword-like protrusion” that then unfolded into a little fan of helicopter blades. It’s difficult to be sure from the transcript, but it seems as though the UFO was turning as it hovered, but these helicopter blades were just some goofy decoration that didn’t spin. The stopped-in-space experience lasted about a minute and a half, and then the device suddenly moved and with great rapidity vanished to the north. But that wasn’t the most astonishing part of the close encounter.

When the object entered the mall parking lot, outside time seemed to stop. The witness told it to John this way: “It seemed at this time there were no cars moving; didn’t hear a thing in the world. Nothing. Just like the world stood still. . . . Didn’t see the movement of a thing. I don’t believe anything was moving on I-20 at the time. I did not hear a truck or a car—it just seemed like I was in a trance. We just sat there and looked at it like there was nothing else in the world but us and the machine. . . . As soon as the machine left, traffic on I-20 came alive and the parking lot became active. It was very noticeable and up to that time there was nothing moving.” (Michael D. Swords, “Unusual Experiences from the Timmerman Files,” International UFO Reporter 27, no. 2 (Summer 2002): 21)

Well, “nothing else in the world” was active. I’m prejudiced because of my knowledge of and friendship with John and having researched the tape recordings myself, so take it for what it’s worth when I say that I think that this is one of the finest cases of the Oz Factor in the UFO encounter files. And the point for this article is: The witnesses felt that the rest of the world was somehow disconnected from themselves and the space just around them, and things were operating differently there. As if they were in a partially removed “bubble” of space? Some kind of overlay not quite fully in touch with the normal? Small areas of overlapped space, light passing in and out, but other stuff? Maybe not. And rate of time? Hard to say.

You and I know how the Oz Factor is typically described, so I won’t labor you with more examples—there are dozens. This is abundant enough in the close encounter literature that it can be called a regular feature, albeit not a universal one. Theorists have their own takes on it. Mostly they are just humbly confused. I am too. But I would add that, for me, it seems more and more like an ability of the UFO phenomenon to manipulate areas of space. In all of these cases, the behavior of light across the boundary seems probably normal, and so we might guess is the behavior of the rest of the electromagnetic forces.

But gravity? Mass-related behaviors? These seem often thwarted somehow—almost as if the gravitational involvement of the Earth itself were taken out of the equation.

 Manipulating space and time

Areas of space manipulated. Bubbles within which things aren’t completely in touch with our normal environment. The Oz Factor. Non-inertial movements. No sonic booms. No air displacement. And that gnawing ETH-stopper: How could they possibly cross all that distant space from there to here?

Maybe they don’t. Or maybe they don’t cross the space as it is normally arrayed in our textbook universe. Maybe they can manipulate space. Bubble the small scale? Bubble the long scale? Mess with mass? Mess with inertia? Go really fast in what space—space normal? Instantly vanish—to what area of space?

I can hear the not-so-distant screaming of the physicists so, acknowledging their superior training, I’ll shut up now.

But I’ll whisper, “Alcubierre drive.” Sorry, obviously no good.

“NASA studying warp bubble ideas.” Sorry, no good.

History of technology: “Crawl, then walk, then run.” Sorry.

“How do they stop a vehicle by seeming to just reach past the intervening car parts and affect it without affecting the nearby driver?”

“What was that really tight mobile force aura around everyone and everything in the 1959 Father Gill case in Boianai, Papua New Guinea?” Oops. Sorry. Irrelevant.