Peeking into the Corners of 1952, Part Three

 

by Michael D. Swords

Intense Interest at the Heart of the Pentagon

Gen. William GarlandThe photo on the right is Brig. Gen. William Garland, who was Maj. Gen. John Samford’s assistant in the Directorate of Intelligence at US Air Force Headquarters in the Pentagon. Because he is known to have been not only open-minded on UFOs, but also believed that he had himself seen one, historians of ufology have made the reasonable assumption that his presence at this level of command explains why the Pentagon took such a positive turn in its attitude in 1952. That is not a terrible hypothesis, but I believe that it is only one factor leading to the debut of this UFO-sympathetic period. Having a prominent officer with this attitude was probably a requirement for uncorking the bottle of UFO interest, but there was a huge number of Air Force officers and other consultants ready to offer their opinions on the phenomenon.

As for personnel below Samford and Garland’s offices, let’s begin with what we know, and then proceed to what we know a little less well. Capt. Edward J. Ruppelt, head of Project Blue Book, is a great help in this.

The leader in the Air Analysis side of USAF intelligence was Col. William A. Adams, who was at the high end of the stack that descended to the UFO desk.

(Bear with me for a minor aside. For years, I was under the impression that we had a good photo of Col. Adams, and I published it as such several times. Now I find that this was wrong—it was a picture of a fine fellow also named William Adams, but not “our” William Adams. Sometime past and before the wrong William Adams showed up, I had found a World War II–era photo of Gen. Carl Spaatz decorating another William A. Adams, with a different face, so maybe this is our guy. Why do I care? It’s just a hang-up I have. I like illustrations. For me, they make history come more alive. My students always smiled much wider when I drew on the blackboard rather than just chalked down linear letters. So, let’s pretend that this is a picture of the real Col. Adams, until I am proven wrong again.)

So, back to the Pentagon intelligence organization chart concerned with UFOs.

This is what Ruppelt (right) found out when he met Adams at the time he was reporting to Samford and Garland. I find this assessment remarkable, even to the point of blowing my mind when I first read it:

“Col. Adams was the Chief of the Topical Intelligence Branch of the D/I [Directorate of Intelligence] , and Col. [Weldon] Smith and Maj. Dewey Fournet worked for him.  He was pretty much sold on the whole thing. I think that Dewey Fournet influenced his thinking to a great extent and he really went to bat for all of Dewey’s ideas. He pushed Fournet’s study of the motions of the UFOs, and he is the one who used to be the most vocal in the briefings and at meetings in regard to Blue Book taking a ‘negative’ attitude. He is the one who became irked in one briefing and asked me if it wasn’t true that if we made a few positive assumptions, we could prove that the UFOs were real.”

That statement is quite revealing. Here is a full-blown, UFOs-are-real colonel at the top of USAF topical (day-to-day) intelligence, and one who was both forcefully vocal in the highest meetings but also pushing for and supporting other UFO-friendly intel studies. I’ll write about Fournet’s study later. But regarding Adams’s comment about what if we just “made a few positive assumptions,” Ruppelt is being coy, because he also  believed that himself. In the notecards in his still extant files, there is one that reads: “My opinion. The flying disks are either interplanetary or they don’t exist.”

That’s worth more than a passing smile. Ruppelt is being intellectually honest. The first thing to note is that he is eliminating all mundane hypotheses if even some UFOs are interplanetary. Here’s what he means: When Blue Book gets a report of an alleged flying disk (or similar aeroform), there is no alternative to the extraterrestrial hypothesis (ETH) except when the witnesses are inaccurate observers. Now Ruppelt knows that not all these cases involve poor observers, so why, as Col. Adams challenges, will he not admit to the ETH? The reason is that our favorite USAF Blue Book chief is, in one specific way, like our not-so-favorite guy, Dr. Edward U. Condon of the later Colorado project. Both Ruppelt and Condon shared a very conservative view of proof. Like Condon, he felt that proof required true physical evidence that was researchable, hands-on, in the laboratory. Without a crashed flying disk or parts of one, UFOs do not prove the ETH. Examining “foreign” technology is, of course, exactly what Wright-Patterson Air Force Base was set up to do—it’s what Col. Howard M. McCoy and Col. Harold E. Watson did in Europe, pulling wreckage from the battlefields, and what Lt. Ruppelt himself did on MiGs before he joined Blue Book. Ruppelt had a strong personality for a lieutenant and was willing to speak truth to power, but would not engage in belief or speculation, no matter how likely it might be.

In his mind, Ruppelt was working an intelligence job, not enjoying some fun research adventure. He was trying to provide a solid Estimate of the Situation that contained actionable intelligence and not unproven conclusions. He absolutely considered it likely that UFOs were real technology. But it was not his job to present his beliefs; instead, he insisted on holding the conservative line.

Just below Adams was Col. Weldon Smith.

Ruppelt says this about Smith: “This man was Dewey Fournet’s boss. He wasn’t quite as sold on the UFOs but he was pretty well sold. He also ‘bought’ Fournet’s ideas and studies. I remember specifically the case of the Burned Scoutmaster [Sonny DesVergers on August 19, 1952]: Col. Smith was ‘sold’ that this was the real thing. He was following the whole show from the Pentagon, through my calls to Fournet and from the wires I was sending back. Just as soon as I got back from the first trip to Florida, I went in to see him and he got quite irked when I said that something about the scoutmaster just didn’t ring true. He said that I was biased and wasn’t giving the man a chance.”

This contains much of interest to me also. To begin with, it shows that Smith was also more than ready to support the UFOs-as-advanced-technology hypothesis. He’s not only “pretty well sold,” but he is very interested in the DesVergers landing case. Why? And how could he be? Historians of ufology will note that in these early days, with the unusual exception of crash claims, the case files are almost devoid of close encounters, especially any leaving physical effects behind. Where are the marks on the ground? Well, here was a landing, or nearly one, with puzzling physical traces. We know that the Pentagon was aware of the case before Blue Book was, and it essentially ordered Ruppelt to hustle down there. Dewey Fournet even sent Ruppelt and the local officers a list of things to do and questions to be sure to ask. That’s the why, but given the problems with the main witness, how could he be that interested?

The answer is that Smith and others would correctly reason that scoutmaster Sonny DesVergers didn’t make much difference in the end. What’s the problem, and what’s the solution? DesVergers had a poor reputation as a prankster well before the case occurred. He gave his first testimony and then began to escalate his claims until they reached the apparently outlandish. His media appearances were full of giant red flags as to his character, and people who knew him had serious reservations. One said: “If he told me the Sun was shining, I’d check the sky.” So how could Col. Smith still maintain an interest?

Here’s the reason: DesVergers’s original testimony wasn’t outlandish and, in fact, seems somewhat ordinary when compared with close encounters of future decades. He did have secondary witnesses who corroborated the basic context of the claim. But crucially, the physical evidence that was taken and tested could not be explained.

The Air Force tested the grass under the UFO hover site and found dramatically damaged roots below the ground, but no obvious damage above ground. No one could figure how this could possibly happen. (And they tried several tests.)

Thus, a high-technology mystery was apparent. Some people threw their hands in the air and refused to deal with it. Some called it the greatest hoax in UFO history, with no justification (scientifically) to make such a statement.

What it really looks like is one of the best early physical trace cases, but with a terrible witness. Ruppelt wrote about this in the context of it being a hoax; he actually believed the latter.

The man on the left was one of my all-time best friends and teaching colleagues at Western Michigan University, Dr. Charles Heller. Charlie joined the Air Force after college in 1953. He was smart, so they shuttled him into intelligence. All the rookies got extensive briefings from intel officers, and one of them was, amazingly, about UFOs. (In case they had to write a report about one.) Doubly amazing, Ruppelt helped out for a while until he fully retired, and so into Charlie’s briefing walked Capt. Edward Ruppelt to do the honors. The most memorable part of that briefing was how excited Ruppelt was as he described the “burnt grass roots” case and how they couldn’t solve it. (The only other case that Charlie remembered from the briefing was one where the Air Force pilot said that he fired at a UFO.)

So, Col. Weldon Smith wasn’t alone in his feeling that the case was significant. Maj. Fournet felt that way too. How many more were of that same view?

Ruppelt says that scientists had talked to him about UFO propulsion theories based upon pure speculations like Einstein and “unified field theory,” and he came up with his own ideas involving alternating magnetic fields and gravity, and metal heating by induction, all related to the DesVergers case. When he visited the RAND Corporation, he talked to one of their scientists about this and he went wild. After running with the idea for a while, the scientist turned on Ruppelt in frustration since Ed would not take a stronger favorable view of the ETH. He said, “What do you want? Does a UFO have to come in and land on your desk at ATIC?”—one more example of the general atmosphere behind the scenes in the world of military and scientific consultants.

It would have been extremely interesting for all of us if the UFOs had decided to engage in multiple, obvious Close Encounters of the Second Kind in 1952. All of these officers whom we have been discussing were dying for a physical-evidence case. This deficit remained true for most of the time of Project Blue Book, but in later years it was caused by the separate issue of the Air Force managing somehow to miss the ones that did take place (even though they were allegedly paying attention). The one chance anyone had to officially hack away at physical-evidence cases was in an era where almost none showed up.

But how far would these intel people have gone with several dozen of these cases? I suspect that we would have cracked the psychological barrier to the ETH being the primary hypothesis back then.

Of course, that didn’t happen. Maybe the UFOnauts had all of this figured out and managed it accordingly. Their 70+ years of managed display does seem eerily well done. Maybe the thought isn’t completely crazy that “they” know far more about all dimensions of what we know and are doing and are always ahead of us—far ahead of us. Veteran Puppet Masters in the new planet Display Game.

That’s enough unregulated thought by me for now. In 1952 Part Four, we will look at more of these gentlemen in Ruppelt’s life, and glimpse what we can behind the secret veil.

 

Read Part One of Peeking into the Corners of 1952.

Read Part Two of Peeking into the Corners of 1952.

Read Part Four of Peeking into the Corners of 1952.

Read Part Five of Peeking into the Corners of 1952.

Read Part Six of Peeking into the Corners of 1952.